Filling In An In-ground Pool
The story of our inground-pool removal, the cost to remove the inground pool, the cost to fill in the inground pool, the process of the inground pool demolition, and the how the inground pool was filled in and our backyard reclaimed! Hint: best home improvement project EVER!!
When we purchased our house seven years ago, the number one thing I did not want was a pool!
So of course, our house came with an in-ground pool.
For years I lobbied to have it filled in, always being vetoed by Hubby and Sonny-boy.
For the first few years that we lived here, Sonny-boy and his buddies would use the pool several times a week. While I disliked the cost and the maintenance, at least someone was using the pool.
Or at least that was the argument Hubby and Sonny-boy would give me.
And the truth is, I refused to clean the pool or add water to it, or prime the filter, or purchase the chemicals, or… well, do just about anything related to the pool. And yes, that did include swimming in it.
Over the years, Sonny-boy went off to college and Hubby was working insane hours so slowly it became my job to add the water so the filter would still run. I also scheduled the opening and closing and picked up after the pool guys. Slowly but surely the slippery slope developed where I was adding water, then chemicals, then cleaning the sides of the pool … pretty soon I could see that I would be vacuuming and skimming and that is when I put my foot down. We hired the pool company to do the weekly maintenance.
They were about $100 a week, but it was either that or marriage counseling, so the cost was negligible by comparison. And all this money was for something that was being used under half a dozen times a year!
Throughout this period, I was still lobbying hard to get the pool filled in. I figured we were spending about $3000 a year on a pool no one used! What a complete waste of money.
All of this came to a head last year (2011) when the pool guys could not get the pool blue. They would come out, clean it, add chemicals, etc, but no amount of shock was clearing the pool water. It turned out that our pool had become porous, and an algae of some-sort-or-another was living in the lining, and could not be removed. The cost to empty the pool, blast the sides, reskim, fix the one broken tile and redo the cool-decking was $15,000. Yup, FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS! To fix a 35-year-old pool that probably didn’t cost that much to install originally.
When we first moved in, I had given a cursory look into filling in the pool, and that cost was approximately $10,000.
Hmmmmm $15,000 to fix a pool we seldom used + the $3000 yearly costs, versus $10,000 to fill it in and be done with the headache and regain a portion of our yard.
Seemed like a no-brainer to me!
Well, over the course of the winter hubby ruminated on the idea. I kept offering to get a few more quotes to fix the pool, and he kept putting it off. I suspected he was coming around to my way of thinking but wasn’t certain.
Three weeks ago, we had a clean-up landscaper over to quote spring cleaning yard work and trim the bushes that enclose our backyard (they are almost 16 feet tall and that is totally beyond us). During casual conversation, we mentioned the issue of the pool and that we only knew of one place that filled in pools in the area. He told us of someone he worked with frequently who specialized in pool-fill-ins, and gave us a name and number.
A few days later, the excavator stopped by, gave us a quote for $7,800 to fill in the pool and that included sod and resodding.
Done! Hubby checked references, and we signed on the dotted line.
Two days later, they were here and starting the work of breaking up the pool.
Max would like to help!
The final empty.
They moved in a small bobcat while the pool was emptying.
He punched hundreds of holes in the pool for water drainage.
Once he got an area weak enough, he’d start collapsing the exterior of the pool and the cool deck.
While no one else was amazed with the bobcat operator, I was simply astounded he didn’t dump the bobcat in the empty pool!
They had intended to fill in the pool with fill the next day, but as luck would have it rain was forecast and they were concerned that we’d have a mudhole in the backyard before the sod could be laid and the inspector signed off on the work.
So, the initial break-up work was done on Thursday, and they did not return to fill in the pool until the following Tuesday.
Some groundwater did sink back in, but we have a guarantee that if the fill-in sinks, they will come back next year and refill and resod the depressed area.
They covered all the sidewalks:
And the grass:
And then the dump trucks started arriving with the clean fill.
In all, we were told that the 10 rounds of trucks (two per time) were dumping 20 yards of fill each time … 200 yards of fill total.
The bobcat driver made himself a path that he kept driving over again and again. Not only did that allow him to reach the furthest end of the pool, but he was basically tamping down the fill as he went!
And they filled it!
After they finished filling in the broken apart pool with the clean fill, they added a layer of topsoil and screened.
The next day, Wednesday, our sprinkler guy (who is all sorts of awesome! Truly, I can’t recommend this guy enough. If anyone in the Buffalo-area needs a recommendation, you can email me!) came in to lay the lines, the inspector came to check the electric, they laid the sod, cleaned up after themselves (they were amazing!) and we now have this:
We had a heater and a sand filter in the garage, as well as electric for the pool lights, the filter, and pipes for the natural gas. That is all gone now too! They dumped the sand into the pool, wheeled that empty container out along with the heater, took all the pipes and the pool cover (a shame that could not be reused on another pool, but it is custom made). We now have a good eighth of our garage back which I am sure hubby will quickly fill with useless stuff.
Also, even though it is only April and the daytime highs are only in the 50s, we still need the new sod watered heavily. The sprinklers did this once in the middle of the night, and once during the day for a little over a week. It was soggy, but that sod grass has greened-up nicely.
All in all, for us, this was a wonderful experience. It took three days total to go from a useless, old pool to a wonderful green yard that we will enjoy thoroughly, especially when I consider we are saving thousands of dollars per year on not having to maintain a pool! If we had done this when we moved in, the fill-in would have paid for itself in three years. Oh well, hindsight is 20-20. I am just glad it is done and we can now enjoy the savings.
It is now a year later and I could not possibly be happier with our decision to fill in our pool. The picture above shows the area a year later, last week to be specific. Not only do we have more green-space in our backyard, we don’t have to deal with pool upkeep. We also no longer worry while on vacation that someone might enter the pool – regardless of how high the arborvitae, or how sturdy the gate lock.
All-in-all this is one of the best decisions we ever made for our homelife!
Update it is now 2018, six years later. It is still my favorite home renovation project to date. I cannot tell you how thrilled I have been to have so much of the backyard reclaimed, to not have the pool costs, to not have the worry of when we go away someone will fall in and hurt themself (and later sue us!). In all that time we have had one small depression at the shallowest point of the fill-in (go figure!). We only notice when we are running over it when playing with the dog. I again want to say how thrilled we are with this project, and the contractor who did it (he’s still in business, and I am still sending out his phone number to those who inquire).
Note: this post originally appeared on my old blog, Coupons, Deals and More
• Disclosure the links in this post may be affiliate links.
• If you enjoyed this post, be sure to sign up for the Ann’s Entitled Life weekly newsletter, and never miss another article!
• For more Renovation projects on Ann’s Entitled Life, click here.